Tooth fairy books often help children learn and grow through the experience of losing a tooth. They provide a structured way for children to understand the physical and emotional changes that come with this developmental milestone. Many books introduce traditions, cultural perspectives, and concepts of personal growth, encouraging children to reflect on change, responsibility, and new beginnings. However, with countless tooth fairy books available, it can be challenging for parents to decide which stories will resonate most with their child. Don’t worry, we are here to help you get started! Here are our top recommendations.
Best Tooth Fairy Books Every Mother Must Explore
The Tooth Fairy and The Enchanted Tooth Box
The Tooth Fairy and The Enchanted Tooth Box by Dr. Joya Lyons. Written in rhyme, the 32-page hardcover follows Brielle, a young child who learns about the magical Enchanted Tooth Box, a device the Tooth Fairy uses to collect teeth from around the world. The story reassures children who may feel anxious or uncertain about losing a tooth, reframing the experience as both natural and enchanting. Beyond its narrative appeal, the book includes an oral health tips page to guide families in teaching children proper dental care habits, reinforcing the importance of maintaining healthy teeth even as baby teeth fall out. Designed to be read aloud, it encourages the creation of a positive family ritual around tooth loss, making the milestone memorable and exciting rather than stressful. Dr. Lyons, both a dentist and mother, brings unique credibility by combining clinical insight with parental sensitivity.
The Night Before the Tooth Fairy
The Night Before the Tooth Fairy is a 32-page softcover children’s tooth fairy book published by Penguin Young Readers Group. It belongs to the Night Before series and targets the age group of approximately 4-8 years. The narrative is patterned after the cadence of Clement C. Moore’s classic “’Twas the Night Before Christmas.” It tells the story of a young boy whose wiggly, loose tooth just won’t fall out. He lies awake in anticipation, excited for the Tooth Fairy’s visit. Through the suspense, this tooth fairy children’s book addresses common anxieties children have about losing teeth, while also generating the excitement and wonder surrounding this milestone.
Fancy Nancy and the Too-Loose Tooth
Fancy Nancy and the Too-Loose Tooth (I Can Read, Level One) by Jane O’Connor, illustrated by Robin Preiss Glasser, addresses the emotional complexity of losing a first tooth through the point of view of the series’ trademark character, Fancy Nancy. Nancy has one loose tooth at home and is deeply concerned it might fall out before she arrives at school. She hopes to get the special tooth-holder necklace given by the school nurse only to students who lose their tooth while at school. Throughout the narrative, she experiments with keeping the tooth intact (eating soft foods, avoiding talking too much, etc.), reflecting both excitement and anxiety. When the tooth finally comes out during her trip to school, Nancy grapples with her sense of fairness and pride: although she still gets the necklace, she feels uncertain if she “deserves” it because the tooth did not technically fall out in class.
The Berenstain Bears and the Tooth Fairy
The Berenstain Bears and the Tooth Fairy is about a Sister Bear, who eagerly awaits her tooth fairy reward. She is surprised to learn that her friend Lizzy received more, sparking curiosity and comparison. With warmth and humor, Mama and Papa Bear guide Sister through understanding that every family’s traditions and Tooth Fairy gifts are different. In just 24 pages, this story offers thoughtful lessons on patience, fairness, and managing expectations, while keeping the magic of childhood beliefs alive for young readers ages 4 to 8.
Dear Tooth Fairy
This interactive book features letters between children and the tooth fairy, providing a unique epistolary format that encourages children to think about writing and communication. After Holly loses her tooth, she is uncertain about giving it to the Tooth Fairy. Over the course of a week, Holly writes letters to the Tooth Fairy, asking questions many children have such as why the Tooth Fairy wants her tooth, what happens afterward, etc. The Tooth Fairy responds in kind, offering reassurance. The book uses removable letters, real‐envelope interactions, and other tactile features to engage young readers.
Silverlicious
Part of the Pinkalicious series, this book follows the title character as she faces the consequences of eating too many sweets when her tooth turns silver. When Pinkalicious loses what she calls her “sweet tooth,” candies suddenly lose their flavor and nothing tastes sweet anymore. Upset, she writes a note to the Tooth Fairy and places it under her pillow. In response, she receives curious messages from mythical characters such as Cupid, the Easter Bunny, and a Christmas elf, none of whom solve her problem. Finally, the Tooth Fairy intervenes with magic and teaches Pinkalicious an important lesson: true sweetness isn’t just in treats, it comes from kindness, generosity, and behaving with a sweet disposition
What Does the Tooth Fairy Do With Our Teeth?
This book by Denise Barry is a creative exploration of the question many children ask: What happens to teeth after the Tooth Fairy collects them? The book presents imaginative possibilities for building fairy castles, forming stars in the sky, or other magical activities, mixing fantasy with wonder to satisfy curiosity. At approximately 34 pages and in hardcover format, it employs purposeful illustrations and accessible language to foster both cognitive engagement and a sense of security. It is well-suited for families seeking to nurture imagination while addressing children’s natural questions about rituals and beliefs.
Here Comes the Tooth Fairy Cat
In Here Comes the Tooth Fairy Cat, Cat loses a tooth and much to his surprise the Tooth Fairy sends him a sidekick: Mouse. Together, Cat and Mouse must complete Tooth Fairy-related errands, which becomes a comedic challenge, since Mouse is just as mischievous and competitive as Cat. The book maintains a humorous, lightly antagonistic between the two characters, with minimal text complemented by expressive illustrations and sight gags. It offers a fresh perspective on the tooth-losing milestone by showing variation in how traditions are fulfilled (here: Cat doesn’t immediately receive the usual tooth fairy visit) and highlights themes of cooperation, patience, and unexpected outcomes.
To Wrap Up:
Now that you have all the top recommendations for tooth fairy Books, take the time to read them together with your child. Sharing these stories does more than prepare children for the experience of losing teeth; it creates meaningful opportunities to talk about growing up, explore cultural diversity, and celebrate the special traditions that make childhood so memorable. When your little one’s tooth fairy adventures move from story time to real life, our Tooth Fairy Box is the perfect keepsake to treasure each milestone along the way!